Soccer Hall of Fame voting since 2004

I’ve not seen this data collected all in one place before, so in the interests of preserving it for posterity, here is what I have pulled together on the recent history of National Soccer Hall of Fame voting since the process underwent a major revamp in 2004. (Before the second major revamp in 2021.)

It’s a work in progress, as I’m still adding “years on ballot” for many players, I have to track down my ballots from a few years, and I have general housekeeping and confirming to do. But here we go.

2023 VOTING (48 votes cast)
Players on Final Ballot: 20 (16 Men, 4 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Landon Donovan (1)4695.83%
2DaMarcus Beasley (1)4593.75%
3Lauren Cheney Holiday (5)4083.33%
4Lori Chalupny3266.67%
5Nick Rimando2960.42%
6Josh McKinney2552.08%
7David Beckham2347.92%
8Cat Reddick Whitehill1735.42%
9Robbie Keane1633.33%
10Pablo Mastroeni1531.25%
11Dwayne DeRosario1429.17%
12Keith Johnson1429.17%
13Jermaine Jones1122.92%
14Thierry Henry918.75%
15Shalrie Joseph816.67%
16Brian Ching510.42%
17Lori Lindsey510.42%
18Maurice Edu48.33%
19Oguchi Onyewu48.33%
20Eddie Johnson24.17%
2022 VOTING (48 votes cast)
Players on Final Ballot: 20 (13 Men, 7 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Clint Dempsey (1)4797.92%
2Shannon Boxx (4)4491.67%
3Hope Solo (3)3981.25%
4Lauren Cheney Holiday (4)3675.00%
5Josh McKinney3572.92%
6David Beckham2756.25%
7Aly Wagner2450.00%
8Heather Mitts1735.42%
9Pablo Mastroeni1633.33%
10Lori Chalupny1531.25%
11Cat Reddick Whitehill1327.08%
11Thierry Henry1327.08%
13Robbie Keane1225.00%
14Oguchi Onyewu1122.92%
15Josh Wolff918.75%
15Shalrie Joseph918.75%
15Maurice Edu918.75%
15Carlos Ruiz918.75%
19Eddie Johnson24.17%
20Brian Ching24.2%
2021 VOTING (48 votes cast)
Players on Final Ballot: 20 (12 Men, 8 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Christie Pearce Rampone4593.80%
2Steve Cherundolo (5)4389.60%
3Hope Solo (2)4185.40%
4Shannon Boxx (3)4083.30%
5Josh McKinney3470.80%
6Lauren Cheney Holiday (3)3062.50%
7Frankie Hejduk (7)2245.80%
8David Beckham (5)1837.50%
9Heather Mitts1429.20%
10Lori Chalupny1327.10%
10Keith Johnson1327.10%
10Aly Wagner1327.10%
14Gregg Berhalter1020.80%
15Pablo Mastroeni816.70%
15Oguchi Onyewu816.70%
17Shalrie Joseph714.60%
18Kevin Hartman612.50%
19Thierry Henry510.40%
19Josh Wolff510.40%
2020 VOTING (178 votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 42 (29 Men, 13 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Carlos Bocanegra (3)12268.50%
2Steve Cherundolo (4)10257.30%
2Hope Solo (1)10257.30%
4Kate Markgraf (7)9352.20%
4Shannon Boxx (2)9352.20%
6Jaime Moreno (7)9050.60%
7Frankie Hejduk (6)8346.60%
8David Beckham (4)8145.50%
9Steve Ralston (7)5530.90%
10Lauren Holiday (2)4827.00%
2019 VOTING (178 votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 44 (30 Men, 14 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Abby Wambach (1)14480.90%
2Carlos Bocanegra (2)11564.61%
3Steve Cherundolo (3)9251.69%
4Shannon Boxx (1)7542.13%
4David Beckham (3)7542.13%
6Kate Markgraf (6)7441.57%
7Frankie Hejduk (5)7341.01%
8Jaime Moreno (6)6536.52%
9Lauren Holiday (1)5530.90%
10Taylor Twellman (6)4826.97%
11Clint Mathis (6)4525.28%
12Gregg Berhalter4324.16%
12Steve Ralston4324.16%
14Ben Olsen4123.03%
15Tony Sanneh3620.22%
2018 VOTING (186 votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 32 (27 Men, 5 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Brad Friedel (1)16488.17%
2Tiffeny Millbrett (3)14075.27%
3Carlos Bocanegra (1)12064.52%
4Kate Sobrero Markgraf (5)11260.22%
5Steve Cherundolo (2)8847.31%
6Frankie Hejduk (4)7238.71%
7Jaime Moreno (5)6836.56%
8Steve Ralston5429.03%
9David Beckham (2)4825.81%
10Clint Mathis (5)4222.58%
10Taylor Twellman (5)4222.58%
12Heather Mitts3619.35%
13Eddie Lewis3418.28%
13Tony Sanneh3418.28%
15Gregg Berhalter3217.20%
16Pablo Mastroeni2815.05%
17Thierry Henry (1)2613.98%
17Ben Olsen2613.98%
17Ally Wagner2613.98%
20Josh Wolff2412.90%
2017 VOTING (174 votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 33 (26 Men, 7 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Briana Scurry (4)12068.97%
2Tiffeny Milbrett (2)10660.92%
3Frankie Hejduk (3)8850.57%
4Steve Cherundolo (1)8448.28%
5Kate Markgraf (4)7844.83%
6David Beckham (1)7241.38%
7Chris Armas (5)6235.63%
8Taylor Twellman (4)6034.48%
9Jaime Moreno (4)5833.33%
9Steve Ralston5833.33%
11Clint Mathis (4)4827.59%
12Gregg Berhalter4626.44%
13Tony Sanneh4425.29%
13Ben Olsen4425.29%
15Jason Kreis (7)4224.14%
15Heather Mitts4224.14%
17Eddie Lewis3419.54%
18Pablo Mastroeni (1)3218.39%
19Brian Ching (1)2614.94%
20Kevin Hartman (1)2413.79%
21Aly Wagner2011.49%
21Josh Wolff2011.49%
23Chris Klein1810.34%
24Ante Razov169.20%
25Jeff Cunningham148.05%
26Pat Onstad105.75%
27Leslie Osborne (1)84.60%
28Chris Albright (1)63.45%
29Tina Ellertson (1)42.30%
30Eddie Gaven (1)21.15%
30Joe Cannon (1)21.15%
2016 VOTING (unknown number of votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 28 (20 Men, 8 Women)
No vote totals are available for the 2016 election, which saw Brandi Chastain as the only nominee from the Player Ballot make it, in her first year of eligibility.
2015 VOTING (96 votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 31 (24 Men, 7 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Kasey Keller (1)9295.83%
2Briana Scurry (2)6365.63%
3Tiffeny Milbrett (1)5557.29%
4Shannon MacMillan (8)4850.00%
5Frankie Hejduk (1)4041.67%
6Jaime Moreno (2)3940.63%
7Taylor Twellman (2)3738.54%
8Steve Ralston3132.29%
9Jason Kreis (5)3031.25%
10Kate Markgraf (3)2930.21%
11Clint Mathis (2)2829.17%
11Chris Armas (3)2829.17%
13Ben Olsen2526.04%
14Eddie Lewis1919.79%
15Chris Henderson1818.75%
16Tiffany Roberts1717.71%
17Robin Fraser1616.67%
18John O’Brien1414.58%
18Gregg Berhalter (1)1414.58%
20Tony Sanneh1313.54%
2014 VOTING (120 votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 27 (19 Men, 8 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Brian McBride (1)11495.00%
2Kristine Lilly (1)11091.67%
3Briana Scurry (1)7764.17%
4Marco Etcheverry6352.50%
5Shannon MacMillan (7)5445.00%
6Jaime Moreno (1)5041.67%
7Taylor Twellman (1)4134.17%
8Kate Markgraf (2)3932.50%
8Cindy Parlow3932.50%
10Jason Kreis (4)3831.67%
11Chris Armas (2)3327.50%
11Clint Mathis (1)3327.50%
13Chris Henderson2722.50%
13Steve Ralston2722.50%
15Robin Fraser2117.50%
16Victor Nogueira2016.67%
16Ben Olsen2016.67%
18Tony Sanneh1613.33%
19Raul Diaz Arce1411.67%
19John O’Brien1411.67%
21Chris Klein1210.00%
22Tiffany Roberts108.33%
23Ante Razov86.67%
24Lorrie Fair32.50%
24Zoran Karic (1)32.50%
2013 VOTING (unknown number of votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 22 (16 Men, 6 Women)
No players received 66.7% of the vote in the initial 2013 balloting. The top five vote-getters were (apparently in alphabetical order) Chris Armas, Marco Etcheverry, Shannon MacMillan, Joe-Max Moore and Cindy Parlow. Moore (in his seventh year on the ballot) was the top point-getter (after voters ranked the five from 5 points for most deserving to 1 for least deserving) and was the only person from the Player Ballot to earn membership in the Hall of Fame in 2013. Voting totals are unavailable.
2012 VOTING (102 votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 31 (24 Men, 7 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Claudio Reyna (1)9896.08%
2Tony Meola (1)9290.20%
3Marco Etcheverry (1)6058.82%
4Joe-Max Moore (6)5957.84%
5Shannon MacMillan (5)5049.02%
6Carlos Valderrama (1)4443.14%
7Cindy Parlow (1)3736.27%
8Peter Vermes (1)3635.29%
9Chris Armas (1)3534.31%
10Jason Kreis (2)3130.39%
2011 VOTING (101 votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 25 (20 Men, 5 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Cobi Jones (1)8887.13%
2Eddie Pope (1)7574.26%
3Earnie Stewart (4)7271.29%
4Marco Etcheverry5756.44%
5Shannon MacMillan (4)5554.46%
6Joe-Max Moore (5)5251.49%
7Cindy Parlow4443.56%
8Carlos Valderrama (7)4342.57%
9Peter Vermes3938.61%
10Chris Armas (1)3332.67%
11Tisha Venturini Hoch2423.76%
12Robin Fraser2120.79%
13Mauricio Cienfuegos1918.81%
14Roy Lassiter1817.82%
14Chris Henderson1817.82%
14Peter Nowak1817.82%
14Mike Burns1817.82%
14Steve Trittschuh1817.82%
19Victor Noguiera1716.83%
20Jason Kreis (1)1615.84%
21Raul Diaz Arce1110.89%
22Tiffany Roberts98.91%
22John O’Brien98.91%
24Danielle Slaton (1)32.97%
24Carlos Llamosa (1)32.97%
2010 VOTING (117 votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 24 (21 Men, 3 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Thomas Dooley (7)8370.94%
2Preki Radosavljevic (3)8068.38%
3Earnie Stewart (3)6858.12%
4Shannon MacMillan (3)6454.70%
5Joe-Max Moore (4)6152.14%
6Marco Etcheverry5950.43%
7Carlos Valderrama (6)5547.01%
8Cindy Parlow4538.46%
9Peter Vermes4437.61%
10Chris Henderson (1)3731.62%
2009 VOTING (159 votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 25 (20 Men, 5 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Jeff Agoos (2)10867.92%
2Joy Fawcett (3)10666.67%
3Preki Radosavljevic (2)9660.38%
4Thomas Dooley (6)8553.46%
5Marco Etcheverry7849.06%
6Earnie Stewart (2)6842.77%
7Joe-Max Moore (3)6742.14%
8Carlos Valderrama (5)5937.11%
9Shannon MacMillan (2)5132.08%
10Peter Vermes5031.45%
2008 VOTING (128 votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 35 (30 Men, 5 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Preki Radosavljevic (1)8767.97%
2Joy Fawcett (2)8667.19%
3Jeff Agoos (1)7558.59%
4Thomas Dooley (5)7155.47%
5Marco Etcheverry6853.13%
6Joe-Max Moore (2)5542.97%
7Earnie Stewart (1)5442.19%
8Carlos Valderrama (4)4132.03%
9Shannon MacMillan (1)3527.34%
9Peter Vermes3527.34%
2007 VOTING (141 votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 62 (47 Men, 15 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Mia Hamm (1)13797.16%
2Julie Foudy (1)11883.69%
3Joy Fawcett (1)9567.38%
4Marco Etcheverry (1)8258.16%
5Thomas Dooley (4)7351.77%
5Joe-Max Moore (1)7351.77%
7Carlos Valderrama (3)6848.23%
8Peter Vermes4431.21%
9Peter Nowak4028.37%
10Mauricio Cienfuegos3524.82%
11Roy Wegerle2920.57%
12Cindy Parlow2618.44%
13Pato Margetic2316.31%
14Roy Lassiter2215.60%
15Mike Burns1913.48%
15Victor Nogueira1913.48%
17John Doyle1712.06%
18Raul Diaz Arce1611.35%
18Mike Sorber1611.35%
20Brian Bliss1510.64%
21Dominic Kinnear149.93%
22Frank Klopas139.22%
23Tisha Venturini-Hoch128.51%
2006 VOTING (113 votes cast | Mine)
Players on Ballot: 57 (47 Men, 10 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Alexi Lalas (1)9584.07%
2Carla Overbeck (1)8575.22%
3Thomas Dooley (3)7162.83%
4Bruce Murray6254.87%
5Carlos Valderrama (2)5649.56%
6Hugo Perez5044.25%
7Peter Vermes4035.40%
8Desmond Armstrong3631.86%
9Mauricio Cienfuegos3430.09%
10Peter Nowak2824.78%
2005 VOTING (123 votes cast)
Players on Ballot: 52 (44 men, 8 women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Marcelo Balboa (1)10887.80%
1Tab Ramos (1)10887.80%
3John Harkes (1)10786.99%
4Thomas Dooley (2)7258.54%
5Hugo Perez6250.41%
6Peter Vermes5746.34%
7Carlos Valderrama (1)5443.90%
8Bruce Murray4234.15%
9Peter Nowak3226.02%
10Roy Wegerle3125.20%
11Mary Harvey2419.51%
12Linda Hamilton2318.70%
13Mike Burns2217.89%
13Pato Margetic2217.89%
15Desmond Armstrong1814.63%
15John Doyle1814.63%
15Perry Van der Beck1814.63%
18Wendy Gebauer1713.82%
19Frank Klopas1613.01%
20Mike Sorber1512.20%
21Sara Whalen1310.57%
22Steve Trittschuh118.94%
23Brian Bliss97.32%
24Debbie Keller75.69%
25Dominic Kinnear64.88%
26Mo Johnston43.25%
26John Kerr, Jr.43.25%
28Eric Eichmann32.44%
28Matt McKeon32.44%
28Janusz Michallik32.44%
31Paul Bravo21.63%
31Mark Simpson21.63%
31Mark Santel21.63%
31Robert Warzycha21.63%
35Ted Eck10.81%
35Mario Gori10.81%
35Francis Okaroh10.81%
35Brandon Pollard10.81%
35Sara Rafanelli10.81%
40Geoff Aunger00.00%
40Jeff Causey00.00%
40Tracey Ducar00.00%
40Richard Farrer00.00%
40Adam Frye00.00%
40Zak Ibsen00.00%
40Mike Lapper00.00%
40John Maessner00.00%
40Holly Manthei00.00%
40Uche Okafor00.00%
40Mark Semioli00.00%
40Diego Sonora00.00%
40David Vaudreuil00.00%
2004 VOTING (73 votes cast)
Players on Ballot: 38 (30 Men, 8 Women)
RkPlayer (Year on Ballot)VotesPct.
1Michelle Akers (1)7095.89%
2Eric Wynalda (1)6893.15%
3Paul Caligiuri (1)6589.04%
4Thomas Dooley (1)4257.53%
4Hugo Perez4257.53%
6Bruce Murray3345.21%
7Roy Wegerle2331.51%
8Fernando Clavijo2027.40%
9Mary Harvey1419.18%
10Desmond Armstrong1216.44%
10Chico Borja1216.44%
10John Doyle1216.44%
10Mike Sorber1216.44%
en_USEnglish