Soccer Hall of Fame voting since 2004

I’ve not seen this data collected all in one place before, so in the interests of preserving it for posterity, here is what I have pulled together on the recent history of National Soccer Hall of Fame voting since the process underwent a major revamp in 2004. (Before the second major revamp in 2021.)

It’s a work in progress, as I’m still adding “years on ballot” for many players, I have to track down my ballots from a few years, and I have general housekeeping and confirming to do. But here we go.

2023 VOTING (48 votes cast)
Players on Final Ballot: 20 (16 Men, 4 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Landon Donovan (1)	46	95.83%
2	DaMarcus Beasley (1)	45	93.75%
3	Lauren Cheney Holiday (5)	40	83.33%
4	Lori Chalupny	32	66.67%
5	Nick Rimando	29	60.42%
6	Josh McKinney	25	52.08%
7	David Beckham	23	47.92%
8	Cat Reddick Whitehill	17	35.42%
9	Robbie Keane	16	33.33%
10	Pablo Mastroeni	15	31.25%
11	Dwayne DeRosario	14	29.17%
12	Keith Johnson	14	29.17%
13	Jermaine Jones	11	22.92%
14	Thierry Henry	9	18.75%
15	Shalrie Joseph	8	16.67%
16	Brian Ching	5	10.42%
17	Lori Lindsey	5	10.42%
18	Maurice Edu	4	8.33%
19	Oguchi Onyewu	4	8.33%
20	Eddie Johnson	2	4.17%

2022 VOTING (48 votes cast)
Players on Final Ballot: 20 (13 Men, 7 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Clint Dempsey (1)	47	97.92%
2	Shannon Boxx (4)	44	91.67%
3	Hope Solo (3)	39	81.25%
4	Lauren Cheney Holiday (4)	36	75.00%
5	Josh McKinney	35	72.92%
6	David Beckham	27	56.25%
7	Aly Wagner	24	50.00%
8	Heather Mitts	17	35.42%
9	Pablo Mastroeni	16	33.33%
10	Lori Chalupny	15	31.25%
11	Cat Reddick Whitehill	13	27.08%
11	Thierry Henry	13	27.08%
13	Robbie Keane	12	25.00%
14	Oguchi Onyewu	11	22.92%
15	Josh Wolff	9	18.75%
15	Shalrie Joseph	9	18.75%
15	Maurice Edu	9	18.75%
15	Carlos Ruiz	9	18.75%
19	Eddie Johnson	2	4.17%
20	Brian Ching	2	4.2%

2021 VOTING (48 votes cast)
Players on Final Ballot: 20 (12 Men, 8 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Christie Pearce Rampone	45	93.80%
2	Steve Cherundolo (5)	43	89.60%
3	Hope Solo (2)	41	85.40%
4	Shannon Boxx (3)	40	83.30%
5	Josh McKinney	34	70.80%
6	Lauren Cheney Holiday (3)	30	62.50%
7	Frankie Hejduk (7)	22	45.80%
8	David Beckham (5)	18	37.50%
9	Heather Mitts	14	29.20%
10	Lori Chalupny	13	27.10%
10	Keith Johnson	13	27.10%
10	Aly Wagner	13	27.10%
14	Gregg Berhalter	10	20.80%
15	Pablo Mastroeni	8	16.70%
15	Oguchi Onyewu	8	16.70%
17	Shalrie Joseph	7	14.60%
18	Kevin Hartman	6	12.50%
19	Thierry Henry	5	10.40%
19	Josh Wolff	5	10.40%

2020 VOTING (178 votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 42 (29 Men, 13 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Carlos Bocanegra (3)	122	68.50%
2	Steve Cherundolo (4)	102	57.30%
2	Hope Solo (1)	102	57.30%
4	Kate Markgraf (7)	93	52.20%
4	Shannon Boxx (2)	93	52.20%
6	Jaime Moreno (7)	90	50.60%
7	Frankie Hejduk (6)	83	46.60%
8	David Beckham (4)	81	45.50%
9	Steve Ralston (7)	55	30.90%
10	Lauren Holiday (2)	48	27.00%

2019 VOTING (178 votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 44 (30 Men, 14 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Abby Wambach (1)	144	80.90%
2	Carlos Bocanegra (2)	115	64.61%
3	Steve Cherundolo (3)	92	51.69%
4	Shannon Boxx (1)	75	42.13%
4	David Beckham (3)	75	42.13%
6	Kate Markgraf (6)	74	41.57%
7	Frankie Hejduk (5)	73	41.01%
8	Jaime Moreno (6)	65	36.52%
9	Lauren Holiday (1)	55	30.90%
10	Taylor Twellman (6)	48	26.97%
11	Clint Mathis (6)	45	25.28%
12	Gregg Berhalter	43	24.16%
12	Steve Ralston	43	24.16%
14	Ben Olsen	41	23.03%
15	Tony Sanneh	36	20.22%

2018 VOTING (186 votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 32 (27 Men, 5 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Brad Friedel (1)	164	88.17%
2	Tiffeny Millbrett (3)	140	75.27%
3	Carlos Bocanegra (1)	120	64.52%
4	Kate Sobrero Markgraf (5)	112	60.22%
5	Steve Cherundolo (2)	88	47.31%
6	Frankie Hejduk (4)	72	38.71%
7	Jaime Moreno (5)	68	36.56%
8	Steve Ralston	54	29.03%
9	David Beckham (2)	48	25.81%
10	Clint Mathis (5)	42	22.58%
10	Taylor Twellman (5)	42	22.58%
12	Heather Mitts	36	19.35%
13	Eddie Lewis	34	18.28%
13	Tony Sanneh	34	18.28%
15	Gregg Berhalter	32	17.20%
16	Pablo Mastroeni	28	15.05%
17	Thierry Henry (1)	26	13.98%
17	Ben Olsen	26	13.98%
17	Ally Wagner	26	13.98%
20	Josh Wolff	24	12.90%

2017 VOTING (174 votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 33 (26 Men, 7 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Briana Scurry (4)	120	68.97%
2	Tiffeny Milbrett (2)	106	60.92%
3	Frankie Hejduk (3)	88	50.57%
4	Steve Cherundolo (1)	84	48.28%
5	Kate Markgraf (4)	78	44.83%
6	David Beckham (1)	72	41.38%
7	Chris Armas (5)	62	35.63%
8	Taylor Twellman (4)	60	34.48%
9	Jaime Moreno (4)	58	33.33%
9	Steve Ralston	58	33.33%
11	Clint Mathis (4)	48	27.59%
12	Gregg Berhalter	46	26.44%
13	Tony Sanneh	44	25.29%
13	Ben Olsen	44	25.29%
15	Jason Kreis (7)	42	24.14%
15	Heather Mitts	42	24.14%
17	Eddie Lewis	34	19.54%
18	Pablo Mastroeni (1)	32	18.39%
19	Brian Ching (1)	26	14.94%
20	Kevin Hartman (1)	24	13.79%
21	Aly Wagner	20	11.49%
21	Josh Wolff	20	11.49%
23	Chris Klein	18	10.34%
24	Ante Razov	16	9.20%
25	Jeff Cunningham	14	8.05%
26	Pat Onstad	10	5.75%
27	Leslie Osborne (1)	8	4.60%
28	Chris Albright (1)	6	3.45%
29	Tina Ellertson (1)	4	2.30%
30	Eddie Gaven (1)	2	1.15%
30	Joe Cannon (1)	2	1.15%

2016 VOTING (unknown number of votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 28 (20 Men, 8 Women)
No vote totals are available for the 2016 election, which saw Brandi Chastain as the only nominee from the Player Ballot make it, in her first year of eligibility.

2015 VOTING (96 votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 31 (24 Men, 7 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Kasey Keller (1)	92	95.83%
2	Briana Scurry (2)	63	65.63%
3	Tiffeny Milbrett (1)	55	57.29%
4	Shannon MacMillan (8)	48	50.00%
5	Frankie Hejduk (1)	40	41.67%
6	Jaime Moreno (2)	39	40.63%
7	Taylor Twellman (2)	37	38.54%
8	Steve Ralston	31	32.29%
9	Jason Kreis (5)	30	31.25%
10	Kate Markgraf (3)	29	30.21%
11	Clint Mathis (2)	28	29.17%
11	Chris Armas (3)	28	29.17%
13	Ben Olsen	25	26.04%
14	Eddie Lewis	19	19.79%
15	Chris Henderson	18	18.75%
16	Tiffany Roberts	17	17.71%
17	Robin Fraser	16	16.67%
18	John O’Brien	14	14.58%
18	Gregg Berhalter (1)	14	14.58%
20	Tony Sanneh	13	13.54%

2014 VOTING (120 votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 27 (19 Men, 8 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Brian McBride (1)	114	95.00%
2	Kristine Lilly (1)	110	91.67%
3	Briana Scurry (1)	77	64.17%
4	Marco Etcheverry	63	52.50%
5	Shannon MacMillan (7)	54	45.00%
6	Jaime Moreno (1)	50	41.67%
7	Taylor Twellman (1)	41	34.17%
8	Kate Markgraf (2)	39	32.50%
8	Cindy Parlow	39	32.50%
10	Jason Kreis (4)	38	31.67%
11	Chris Armas (2)	33	27.50%
11	Clint Mathis (1)	33	27.50%
13	Chris Henderson	27	22.50%
13	Steve Ralston	27	22.50%
15	Robin Fraser	21	17.50%
16	Victor Nogueira	20	16.67%
16	Ben Olsen	20	16.67%
18	Tony Sanneh	16	13.33%
19	Raul Diaz Arce	14	11.67%
19	John O’Brien	14	11.67%
21	Chris Klein	12	10.00%
22	Tiffany Roberts	10	8.33%
23	Ante Razov	8	6.67%
24	Lorrie Fair	3	2.50%
24	Zoran Karic (1)	3	2.50%

2013 VOTING (unknown number of votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 22 (16 Men, 6 Women)
No players received 66.7% of the vote in the initial 2013 balloting. The top five vote-getters were (apparently in alphabetical order) Chris Armas, Marco Etcheverry, Shannon MacMillan, Joe-Max Moore and Cindy Parlow. Moore (in his seventh year on the ballot) was the top point-getter (after voters ranked the five from 5 points for most deserving to 1 for least deserving) and was the only person from the Player Ballot to earn membership in the Hall of Fame in 2013. Voting totals are unavailable.

2012 VOTING (102 votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 31 (24 Men, 7 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Claudio Reyna (1)	98	96.08%
2	Tony Meola (1)	92	90.20%
3	Marco Etcheverry (1)	60	58.82%
4	Joe-Max Moore (6)	59	57.84%
5	Shannon MacMillan (5)	50	49.02%
6	Carlos Valderrama (1)	44	43.14%
7	Cindy Parlow (1)	37	36.27%
8	Peter Vermes (1)	36	35.29%
9	Chris Armas (1)	35	34.31%
10	Jason Kreis (2)	31	30.39%

2011 VOTING (101 votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 25 (20 Men, 5 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Cobi Jones (1)	88	87.13%
2	Eddie Pope (1)	75	74.26%
3	Earnie Stewart (4)	72	71.29%
4	Marco Etcheverry	57	56.44%
5	Shannon MacMillan (4)	55	54.46%
6	Joe-Max Moore (5)	52	51.49%
7	Cindy Parlow	44	43.56%
8	Carlos Valderrama (7)	43	42.57%
9	Peter Vermes	39	38.61%
10	Chris Armas (1)	33	32.67%
11	Tisha Venturini Hoch	24	23.76%
12	Robin Fraser	21	20.79%
13	Mauricio Cienfuegos	19	18.81%
14	Roy Lassiter	18	17.82%
14	Chris Henderson	18	17.82%
14	Peter Nowak	18	17.82%
14	Mike Burns	18	17.82%
14	Steve Trittschuh	18	17.82%
19	Victor Noguiera	17	16.83%
20	Jason Kreis (1)	16	15.84%
21	Raul Diaz Arce	11	10.89%
22	Tiffany Roberts	9	8.91%
22	John O’Brien	9	8.91%
24	Danielle Slaton (1)	3	2.97%
24	Carlos Llamosa (1)	3	2.97%

2010 VOTING (117 votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 24 (21 Men, 3 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Thomas Dooley (7)	83	70.94%
2	Preki Radosavljevic (3)	80	68.38%
3	Earnie Stewart (3)	68	58.12%
4	Shannon MacMillan (3)	64	54.70%
5	Joe-Max Moore (4)	61	52.14%
6	Marco Etcheverry	59	50.43%
7	Carlos Valderrama (6)	55	47.01%
8	Cindy Parlow	45	38.46%
9	Peter Vermes	44	37.61%
10	Chris Henderson (1)	37	31.62%

2009 VOTING (159 votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 25 (20 Men, 5 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Jeff Agoos (2)	108	67.92%
2	Joy Fawcett (3)	106	66.67%
3	Preki Radosavljevic (2)	96	60.38%
4	Thomas Dooley (6)	85	53.46%
5	Marco Etcheverry	78	49.06%
6	Earnie Stewart (2)	68	42.77%
7	Joe-Max Moore (3)	67	42.14%
8	Carlos Valderrama (5)	59	37.11%
9	Shannon MacMillan (2)	51	32.08%
10	Peter Vermes	50	31.45%

2008 VOTING (128 votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 35 (30 Men, 5 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Preki Radosavljevic (1)	87	67.97%
2	Joy Fawcett (2)	86	67.19%
3	Jeff Agoos (1)	75	58.59%
4	Thomas Dooley (5)	71	55.47%
5	Marco Etcheverry	68	53.13%
6	Joe-Max Moore (2)	55	42.97%
7	Earnie Stewart (1)	54	42.19%
8	Carlos Valderrama (4)	41	32.03%
9	Shannon MacMillan (1)	35	27.34%
9	Peter Vermes	35	27.34%

2007 VOTING (141 votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 62 (47 Men, 15 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Mia Hamm (1)	137	97.16%
2	Julie Foudy (1)	118	83.69%
3	Joy Fawcett (1)	95	67.38%
4	Marco Etcheverry (1)	82	58.16%
5	Thomas Dooley (4)	73	51.77%
5	Joe-Max Moore (1)	73	51.77%
7	Carlos Valderrama (3)	68	48.23%
8	Peter Vermes	44	31.21%
9	Peter Nowak	40	28.37%
10	Mauricio Cienfuegos	35	24.82%
11	Roy Wegerle	29	20.57%
12	Cindy Parlow	26	18.44%
13	Pato Margetic	23	16.31%
14	Roy Lassiter	22	15.60%
15	Mike Burns	19	13.48%
15	Victor Nogueira	19	13.48%
17	John Doyle	17	12.06%
18	Raul Diaz Arce	16	11.35%
18	Mike Sorber	16	11.35%
20	Brian Bliss	15	10.64%
21	Dominic Kinnear	14	9.93%
22	Frank Klopas	13	9.22%
23	Tisha Venturini-Hoch	12	8.51%

2006 VOTING (113 votes cast \| Mine)
Players on Ballot: 57 (47 Men, 10 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Alexi Lalas (1)	95	84.07%
2	Carla Overbeck (1)	85	75.22%
3	Thomas Dooley (3)	71	62.83%
4	Bruce Murray	62	54.87%
5	Carlos Valderrama (2)	56	49.56%
6	Hugo Perez	50	44.25%
7	Peter Vermes	40	35.40%
8	Desmond Armstrong	36	31.86%
9	Mauricio Cienfuegos	34	30.09%
10	Peter Nowak	28	24.78%

2005 VOTING (123 votes cast)
Players on Ballot: 52 (44 men, 8 women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Marcelo Balboa (1)	108	87.80%
1	Tab Ramos (1)	108	87.80%
3	John Harkes (1)	107	86.99%
4	Thomas Dooley (2)	72	58.54%
5	Hugo Perez	62	50.41%
6	Peter Vermes	57	46.34%
7	Carlos Valderrama (1)	54	43.90%
8	Bruce Murray	42	34.15%
9	Peter Nowak	32	26.02%
10	Roy Wegerle	31	25.20%
11	Mary Harvey	24	19.51%
12	Linda Hamilton	23	18.70%
13	Mike Burns	22	17.89%
13	Pato Margetic	22	17.89%
15	Desmond Armstrong	18	14.63%
15	John Doyle	18	14.63%
15	Perry Van der Beck	18	14.63%
18	Wendy Gebauer	17	13.82%
19	Frank Klopas	16	13.01%
20	Mike Sorber	15	12.20%
21	Sara Whalen	13	10.57%
22	Steve Trittschuh	11	8.94%
23	Brian Bliss	9	7.32%
24	Debbie Keller	7	5.69%
25	Dominic Kinnear	6	4.88%
26	Mo Johnston	4	3.25%
26	John Kerr, Jr.	4	3.25%
28	Eric Eichmann	3	2.44%
28	Matt McKeon	3	2.44%
28	Janusz Michallik	3	2.44%
31	Paul Bravo	2	1.63%
31	Mark Simpson	2	1.63%
31	Mark Santel	2	1.63%
31	Robert Warzycha	2	1.63%
35	Ted Eck	1	0.81%
35	Mario Gori	1	0.81%
35	Francis Okaroh	1	0.81%
35	Brandon Pollard	1	0.81%
35	Sara Rafanelli	1	0.81%
40	Geoff Aunger	0	0.00%
40	Jeff Causey	0	0.00%
40	Tracey Ducar	0	0.00%
40	Richard Farrer	0	0.00%
40	Adam Frye	0	0.00%
40	Zak Ibsen	0	0.00%
40	Mike Lapper	0	0.00%
40	John Maessner	0	0.00%
40	Holly Manthei	0	0.00%
40	Uche Okafor	0	0.00%
40	Mark Semioli	0	0.00%
40	Diego Sonora	0	0.00%
40	David Vaudreuil	0	0.00%

2004 VOTING (73 votes cast)
Players on Ballot: 38 (30 Men, 8 Women)
Rk	Player (Year on Ballot)	Votes	Pct.
1	Michelle Akers (1)	70	95.89%
2	Eric Wynalda (1)	68	93.15%
3	Paul Caligiuri (1)	65	89.04%
4	Thomas Dooley (1)	42	57.53%
4	Hugo Perez	42	57.53%
6	Bruce Murray	33	45.21%
7	Roy Wegerle	23	31.51%
8	Fernando Clavijo	20	27.40%
9	Mary Harvey	14	19.18%
10	Desmond Armstrong	12	16.44%
10	Chico Borja	12	16.44%
10	John Doyle	12	16.44%
10	Mike Sorber	12	16.44%